Dr. Vavra's Main Menu

The KISS Curriculum

Dr. Vavra's 
Free, On-Line
Grammar Course
Free Course Menu

More Level 5 Exercises

The Opening Paragraphs of Chapter One of
Nathaniel Hawthorne's The Scarlet Letter
Answer Key for Level 5
     Words that remained  to be explained (and some for which a better explanation can now be provided) are in 18-point bold black, with their functions indicated after them. The font size of words aleady analyzed has been decreased. 

Spaces Missing between Words? (Click here for an explanation.)

 

     A throng {of bearded men}, {in sad-coloured garments and grey 

steeple-crowned hats}, inter-mixed {with women}, some Note #1

wearing hoods, and others Note #1 bareheaded,

was assembled {in front} {of a wooden edifice}, [the door {of  which}

was heavily timbered {with oak}, and studded {with iron spikes}.] / 

     The founders {of a new colony}, [whatever Utopia {of human 

virtue and happiness} they might originally project,] have invariably

recognised it {among their earliest practical necessities} to allot 

(Inf - Delayed Subject of ellipsed "to be" Note #2) a portion {of 

the virgin soil} {as a cemetery}, and another portion {as the site} 

{of a prison}. {In accordance} {with this rule} it may safely be 

assumed [that (Clause functions as a delayed subject to the 

preceding "it.")  the forefathers {of Boston} had built the first 

prison-house somewhere {in the Vicinity} {of Cornhill}, almost as 

seasonably [as they marked out the first burial-ground, {on Isaac 

Johnson's lot}, and {round about his grave}, [which subsequently 

became the nucleus {of all the congregated sepulchres} {in the old 

churchyard} {of King's Chapel}.]]] / Certain it is [that, (Clause 

functions as a delayed subject to the preceding "it.") some 

fifteen or twenty years (NuA) {after the settlement} {of  the town}, 

the wooden jail was already marked {with weather-stains and other 

indications} {of age}, [which gave a yet darker aspect {to its 

beetle-browed and gloomy front}.]] /  The rust{on the ponderous 

iron-work} {of its oaken door} looked more antique {than anything 

else} {in the New World}. / {Like all} [that pertains {to crime},] it

seemed never to have known a youthful era.{Before this ugly 

edifice}, and {between it and the wheel-track} {of the street}, was a

grass-plot, much overgrown {with burdock, pig-weed, apple-pern,

and such unsightly vegetation}, [which evidently found something 

congenial Note #3 {in the soil} [that had so early borne the black 

flower {of civilised society}, a prison (Appositive to "flower").]]

/ But {on one side} {of the portal}, and rooted almost {at the threshold},

was a wild rose-hush, covered, {in this month} {of June}, {with its 

delicate gems}, [which might be imagined to offer Note #4 their 

fragrance and fragile beauty {to the prisoner} [as he went in,] and 

{to the condemned criminal}[as he came forth {to his doom},] {in token}

[that the deep heart {of Nature} could pity and be kind {to him}.]] / 
 

Project Gutenberg
scarlt12.zip

Notes

1. There are at least two equally acceptable explanations for  "some wearing hoods" and "others bareheaded." "Some" and "others" can be considered appositives to  "throng," "men," or "women." (Note the ambiguity -- does it mean "some" and "others" of both the men and women, or just the men, or just the women?) If "some" and "others" are considered appositives, then "wearing" is a simple gerundive modifying "some." "Bareheaded" can then be explained as either a predicate adjective after an ellipsed "being" ("others *being* bareheaded") or as a post-positioned adjective to "others."
     The other explanation is to view both phrases as noun absolutes functioning adverbially. (To fit the definition of noun absolute, one needs the ellipsed "being.")

2. Limiting the number of concepts and terms allowed for explanations sometimes results in the need for longer explanations, but it is not, I hope, extremely difficult. First, let's insert the ellipsed infinitive -- "recognized it "to be* (among ... necessities) to allot ...." The prepositional phrase ("among ... necessities") can now be considered as either a predicate adjective to "it," or as an adverb to  "to be." (Note the parallel to the clause construction -- "recognized that it was among -- necessities to allot ....") The infinitive phrase is the direct object of "recognized." The subject of that phrase, "it," means "to allot ...." Thus the infinitive phrase "to allot ..." functions as a delayed subject.

3. Although I prefer to see "congenial" as a predicate adjective after an ellipsed "to be," one could probably also consider it as a post-positioned adjective. I prefer the infinitive explanation because it binds "something *to be* congenial" as an infinitive phrase which is then the direct object of "found." The explanation using the post-positioned adjective makes "something" the direct object, but the sentence does not really mean that they found "something."

4. Because "might be imagined" is passive, "to offer" is a retained direct object.
 
 

Progress
Total Words = 345 Words %
L1: In Prep Phrases  185  54
L1: + Adj & Adverbs 53 69
+ L2: S / V / C 75 91
+ L3: Clauses 6 92
+ L4: Verbals 15 97
+ Eight Other 11 100

Return to the Level Five Menu